Roof Insurance Claims in Minnesota
A roof insurance claim in Minnesota is between you and your insurer, and state law limits what a roofer may do in it: a roofer can inspect, document and estimate, but may not pay your deductible, interpret your policy or negotiate the claim for you. You can also cancel if the claim is denied, and a door-to-door contract has its own cancel rule. None of this is legal advice.
What a Roofer May Not Do on Your Insurance Claim
On your insurance claim, a Minnesota roofer may not pay or promise to pay any part of your deductible, may not reward you for an inspection, a claim or a referral, may not interpret your policy or advise you on coverage, and may not adjust the claim for you unless licensed as a public adjuster.
These rules apply to residential contractors, which includes roofers, and the Commissioner of Labor and Industry enforces them. Both you and your insurer can sue a contractor who breaks them.
No deductible deals
A roofer may not advertise or promise to pay all or part of your insurance deductible, directly or indirectly, to win the job.
No rewards
A roofer may not pay or compensate you for allowing an inspection, filing a claim or referring neighbors.
No policy advice
A roofer may not interpret your policy or tell you what your coverage or duties are.
No adjusting
A roofer may not adjust or negotiate your claim with the insurer unless they hold a Minnesota public adjuster license.
What a Roofer May Do on Your Insurance Claim
On your insurance claim, a Minnesota roofer may inspect the roof, document the damage, and give you a written estimate, and any repair agreement must include a good-faith, itemized and detailed estimate of the services and materials.
The roofer must also give you written notice of these rules with the initial estimate, and the adjuster or insurer must give you notice too. Separately, licensed contractors must put the scope, materials and price in writing. Before anyone gets on your roof, check the license on the DLI lookup or with our guide to checking a roofer license in Minnesota.
Required with the estimate
Written notice
The roofer's initial estimate must come with written notice of these claim rules.
Your 72-Hour Right to Cancel If the Claim Is Denied
If your insurer denies the claim, you can cancel a roofing contract that was to be paid from insurance proceeds within 72 hours after the insurer notifies you of the denial.
Cancel by written notice to the contractor's address in the contract. If you mail it, the notice counts once it is properly addressed, stamped and in the mailbox. Within ten days the contractor must return any payments you made, though they may still be paid for emergency services already performed. Before you sign, the roofer must give you this right in bold type of at least 10 points, along with a detachable NOTICE OF CANCELLATION form.
After a denial
72 hours
Your window to cancel an insurance-funded roofing contract, starting when the insurer tells you the claim is denied.
Storm damage on your roof?
Our local roofer will inspect your roof and write up what they find before you call your insurer. Send a few details or call (651) 427-2051.
Public Adjuster or Roofer: Who Speaks for You?
On a roof claim, you speak for yourself with your insurer, or a licensed public adjuster can speak for you; a roofer may not negotiate or adjust the claim unless they also hold a public adjuster license.
In Minnesota a public adjuster must be licensed by the Department of Commerce, pass an exam, post a $10,000 surety bond and submit fingerprints. A public adjuster may not have an interest in a construction firm, may not solicit clients between 8 p.m. and 8 a.m., and may not accept referral fees or kickbacks. You can cancel a public adjuster contract within 72 hours after signing it, and payments must be returned within ten business days. You do not have to hire one; you can deal with the insurer's adjuster yourself.
Roofer
- Inspects and documents damage
- Gives a detailed, itemized estimate
- Does the repair or replacement
- May not interpret your policy or adjust the claim
Licensed public adjuster
- Licensed and bonded through Commerce
- Represents you in negotiating the claim
- May not own part of a construction firm
- Contract can be canceled within 72 hours of signing
The Door-to-Door 3-Day Cancel Rule
Under Minnesota's door-to-door rule, if you sign a contract with a roofer who sold it to you at your home, you can generally cancel until midnight of the third business day after the sale.
This is a separate right from the 72-hour claim-denial right. It matters most after hail and wind storms, when roofers knock on doors. Cancel in writing and keep a copy. For more on storms, see hail damage roof repair and storm damage roof repair.
Home solicitation sale
3 business days
You can generally cancel until midnight of the third business day after a sale made at your home.
Your Cancellation Rights at a Glance
Your cancellation rights on a Minnesota roof claim are three separate deadlines: 72 hours after a claim denial for a roofing contract, three business days for a door-to-door sale, and 72 hours after signing for a public adjuster contract.
More than one can apply to the same contract. When in doubt, cancel in writing as early as you can and keep proof of when you sent it.
| Right | When it applies | Deadline |
|---|---|---|
| Cancel after claim denial | Roofing contract paid from insurance | 72 hours after the insurer notifies you of the denial |
| Door-to-door cancel | Contract sold at your home | Midnight of the third business day after the sale |
| Public adjuster cancel | Contract with a public adjuster | 72 hours after signing |
What Kind of Roof Damage Does Insurance Cover?
Homeowners insurance usually covers roof damage from hail, wind, fire and the weight of ice and snow, but not wear and tear, maintenance or neglect.
Your own policy sets the details, and many Minnesota policies have narrowed. Some now pay for hail and wind damage only when shingles or siding are punctured or torn and no longer keep water out. Minnesota law is silent on exclusions for cosmetic hail or wind damage, so a dented but watertight roof may not be paid for.
Some policies also carry a separate wind and hail deductible on top of the usual one. It can be 1% or more of the home's replacement value, which runs into thousands of dollars. Ask your agent what your policy covers before a storm, because a roofer may not interpret the policy for you.
Hail and wind
Standard policies cover both. Some Minnesota policies pay only when shingles are punctured or torn, not just marked.
Ice and snow
The weight of ice and snow is a covered peril. Water an ice dam pushes inside is usually covered too, but removing the ice is not.
Wear and tear
Old, worn shingles and skipped maintenance are generally not covered. Fixing them is the owner's job.
Slow leaks
Seepage and leaks that build up over time are generally excluded. Report new storm damage to your insurer quickly, since late notice can cost you coverage.
If a storm left your roof leaking, see roof leak repair. For worn shingles that no policy will pay for, see roof repair.
Will Insurance Replace a 20-Year-Old Roof?
Insurance may replace a 20-year-old roof after covered storm damage, but an older roof is often paid at a depreciated value, not full replacement cost.
Replacement cost pays to repair or replace the roof with nothing taken off for age. Actual cash value pays that cost minus depreciation, the value lost to age, wear and tear, or condition. Insurers usually work out depreciation from the roof's condition, what a new one costs and how long it normally lasts.
Your policy sets the age at which this kicks in, not one statewide rule. In Minnesota, insurers have been switching roofs 15 years or older from replacement cost to actual cash value. Many homeowners only learn of the change when they file a claim.
Other policies use a roof payment schedule for wind and hail damage. It pays a set share of the cost based on the roof's age and material. On one Midwest insurer's sample schedule, a 20-year-old standard shingle roof gets 60% of the cost.
The gap comes out of your pocket. Say a new roof costs $30,000, your deductible is $3,000 and the insurer sends $20,000. You still need $13,000 to finish the job. Ask your agent every year what the policy would pay on your roof, because the answer can change. To judge your roof's age and condition, see how long a roof lasts in Minnesota.
| Roof age | Standard asphalt shingles | Class 3 or 4 impact-resistant roof |
|---|---|---|
| New | 100% | 100% |
| 5 years | 90% | 92% |
| 10 years | 80% | 82% |
| 15 years | 70% | 72% |
| 20 years | 60% | 60.5% |
| 25 years | 50% | 50% |
| 30 years | 40% | 40% |
Share of the repair or replacement cost paid for wind and hail damage on one Midwest insurer's sample schedule. Your own schedule, if your policy has one, is in your policy documents. Impact-resistant roofs hold their value a little longer; see impact-resistant shingles.
Not sure the damage is worth a claim?
Our local roofer will look at the roof and price the repair, so you can weigh it against your deductible. Call (651) 427-2051.
How to Handle a Roof Insurance Claim
To handle a roof insurance claim, document the damage, have a licensed roofer inspect and estimate it, report the claim to your insurer, meet the insurer's adjuster, and sign a repair contract only once you understand your cancel rights.
Read your policy yourself or ask your insurer or a licensed public adjuster about coverage, because a roofer is not allowed to advise you on it. If you are planning a full roof replacement, our page on roof estimates explains what a detailed estimate should show.
- 1
Document
Photograph the roof, gutters, siding and any interior damage, and note the date of the storm.
- 2
Check the roofer
Check the roofer's license on the DLI lookup before an inspection.
- 3
Inspection and estimate
The roofer inspects and gives you an itemized estimate with written notice of these claim rules.
- 4
Report the claim
You report the claim to your insurer, who assigns an adjuster to inspect the damage.
- 5
Contract
You sign a repair contract that includes the boldface cancel notice and a detachable cancel form.
- 6
Repair
The roofer does the work once the claim and contract are settled.
If a licensed contractor's fraud or failure to perform costs you money, Minnesota's Contractor Recovery Fund may help, but it only covers licensed contractors, which is one more reason to check the license first.
Roof Insurance Claim FAQs
Can a roofer pay or waive my insurance deductible in Minnesota?
No. Minnesota law bars residential contractors from paying or promising to pay all or part of your deductible, directly or indirectly. An offer to do so is a red flag.
Can my roofer negotiate with my insurance company?
No, unless the roofer also holds a Minnesota public adjuster license. Without one, a contractor may not interpret your policy, advise you on coverage, or adjust the claim.
How do I cancel a roofing contract after my claim is denied?
Send written notice to the contractor's address in the contract within 72 hours after your insurer tells you the claim is denied. The contractor must return your payments within ten days, less any emergency services already done.
Do I need a public adjuster for a roof claim?
No. A public adjuster is optional. If you hire one, check that they are licensed by Minnesota Commerce, and know you can cancel their contract within 72 hours of signing.
Will a stronger roof lower my insurance premium?
It can. Minnesota requires insurers to offer a discount for homes built to the IBHS FORTIFIED standard with a hail supplement. The state-set threshold discounts are 35% to 40% on the wind and hail part of the premium. For Class 4 shingles alone, ask your insurer; see impact-resistant shingles.
What do insurance adjusters look for on roofs?
Adjusters look for damage that stops the roof working, not just marks on it. On asphalt shingles that means fractures, often easiest to see from the underside, and bruises that feel soft under a fingertip. A bruise is where hail knocked off granules, exposed the asphalt and cracked the mat beneath. Valleys, tab edges and overlaps get a close look. Granule loss on its own is not counted as functional damage.
How bad does hail damage have to be to replace a roof?
Bad enough to break the shingles, not just scuff them. Hail about 1 inch across can damage light 3-tab shingles, and about 1.25 inches can damage heavier laminated ones. Whether the insurer pays for a repair or a whole roof then depends on your policy and the adjuster's findings. Repeated small hail also ages shingles faster, which leaves them weaker in the next big storm. See hail damage roof repair.
Will 2-inch hail damage a roof?
Very likely on asphalt shingles. Two inches is well above the sizes at which 3-tab and laminated shingles start to break. Hail that big falls somewhere in Minnesota on 7 to 8 days a year on average. Have the roof inspected before you decide on a claim.
Will homeowners insurance cover ice dam damage?
Usually for the water damage, not for removing the ice. Water an ice dam pushes into ceilings and walls, and damage from the weight of snow and ice, are typically covered. Removing the dam is treated as maintenance and is your cost. An insurer may refuse if poor upkeep caused the damage, so report it promptly. See ice dam removal and ice dam prevention.
Is it smart to submit an insurance claim for your roof?
It usually is when repairs cost clearly more than your deductible, and usually is not when they cost about the same or less. Check for a separate wind and hail deductible first. A paid claim can raise your premium or end a claim-free discount. In Minnesota, three or more covered weather losses over $10,000 each in five years can lead to nonrenewal. Asking your agent about a possible claim does not count as a claim.
Get a roof damage estimate
Send us the details of the damage and we pass them to our local roofer. The roofer inspects and gives you an itemized estimate; your claim stays between you and your insurer.
Call now (651) 427-2051 Roofing in North Branch and the towns around it